Payments

2026 Payment Processor Report: holds, reserves, fees and how hard it is to leave

We read what Square, Clover, Toast, Stripe and PayPal publish about getting paid, getting held and getting out, and put it side by side.

By Mike Akop, founderPublished 14 min read

Instant payout fees listed by Square, Clover, Toast, Stripe and PayPal, shown as bars from 1.5% to 1.95%
On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Key findings
  3. Card rates and instant payout fees
  4. Payout timing, holds and reserves
  5. Chargeback fees and response windows
  6. Contracts, hardware and data
  7. What changed since November 8
  8. How we built this report
  9. Download the data and cite it
  10. Every processor page behind the data
  11. Where MazalPOS fits
  12. Common questions

Key takeaways

  • All five charge 1.5% to 1.95% for instant payouts.
  • Toast, Stripe and PayPal charge $15 to $20 per chargeback; Square charges none.
  • Clover and Toast publish auto-renewing contracts with 30 days’ notice to end.
  • Only Square and Stripe publish a saved card export to a new processor.

The short answer

All five processors charge 1.5% to 1.95% to pay you out instantly, three of them charge $15 to $20 on every chargeback, and two of them, Clover and Toast, publish contracts that renew unless you give 30 days’ written notice. Only Square and Stripe publish a way to take your customers’ saved cards with you.

This report puts 55 published policies side by side across 5 processors, each with a link to the processor’s own page and the date we checked it. 5 of the 55 cells say “not published” because we could not find the number on the processor’s own pages.

Key findings

  1. All five processors charge for instant payouts: 1.5% at Stripe and PayPal, 1.75% at Clover and Toast, and 1.95% at Square. On a $1,000 instant transfer that is $15.00 to $19.50.
  2. Three of the five publish a fee on every chargeback: $15 at Toast (charged even when you win), $15 at Stripe (plus $15 more to contest it) and $20 at PayPal for card chargebacks. Square says it charges none; Clover’s pages we read list no amount.
  3. Published dispute deadlines run from 7 days at Square to as long as 21 days at Stripe, which usually allows 7 to 21 days by card network. Toast gives 15 calendar days and PayPal 10 days for a claim. Stripe, Toast and PayPal say a missed deadline means you lose.
  4. Stripe makes a new account wait 7 to 14 days for its first payout and says that wait cannot be waived. PayPal says held funds are usually held for up to 21 days.
  5. Two of the five, Clover and Toast, publish contracts that renew on their own and need 30 days’ written notice to end. Clover’s published terms start with a three-year term; Toast’s early termination fee on pay-as-you-go is $150 for each month left.
  6. Only two of the five, Square and Stripe, publish a way to move customers’ saved cards to a new processor, and both send them only to a PCI DSS Level 1 processor. Square says it takes up to two weeks.
  7. A reserve can outlast the account: Clover’s published terms let the processor keep a reserve for 10 months after termination, and PayPal says some businesses may never fully remove a reserve.
  8. Four of the five publish an in-person card rate. On a $50 sale the listed base rates come to $1.24 at PayPal, $1.25 to $1.40 at Clover, $1.40 at Stripe and $1.45 on Square’s entry plan. Toast does not publish a number.

Card rates and instant payout fees

What each processor lists for a card sale and for getting paid out in minutes instead of days.

PolicySquareCloverToastStripePayPal
In-person card rate2.6% + 15¢ on the entry plan (2.5% + 15¢ on Plus, 2.4% + 15¢ on Premium)
Source · Our page
2.6% + 10¢ (Starter) or 2.3% + 10¢ (Retail Growth) on its online retail plans
Source · Our page
Not published. The pricing page says “simple, flat rate” without a number
Source · Our page
2.7% + 5¢ for domestic cards in person
Source · Our page
2.29% + 9¢ for card present sales
Source · Our page
Online or typed-in card rate3.3% + 30¢ online on the entry plan; 3.5% + 15¢ typed in or card on file
Source · Our page
3.5% + 10¢ when card details are typed in; online store rate not published
Source · Our page
Not published
Source · Our page
2.9% + 30¢ online; plus 0.5% for manually entered cards
Source · Our page
2.99% + 49¢ standard cards online; 3.49% + 49¢ PayPal Checkout; 3.49% + 9¢ typed in at the counter
Source · Our page
Instant payout fee1.95% per instant or same-day transfer
Source · Our page
1.75% (Rapid Deposit)
Source · Our page
1.75% (Instant Deposit)
Source · Our page
1.5%, 50¢ minimum
Source · Our page
1.50%, 50¢ minimum (Instant Transfer)
Source · Our page

Payout timing, holds and reserves

How long money normally takes to reach the bank, and what each processor says about holding it back.

PolicySquareCloverToastStripePayPal
Standard payout timingNext business day for payments before 5 PM PT; no standard transfers on Saturdays
Source · Our page
1 to 3 business days (standard funding schedule)
Source · Our page
Next business day if batched before 9:30 p.m. ET, otherwise two business days
Source · Our page
2 business days in the US; first payout 7 to 14 days after the first live payment, which Stripe says cannot be waived
Source 1 · Source 2 · Our page
1 to 3 business days to a bank, no fee
Source · Our page
When funds get heldAll transfers stop during a review, which Square says it usually finishes within one business day
Source · Our page
Most funding holds released 24 to 48 hours after you finish the required steps
Source · Our page
Terms let Toast temporarily suspend or delay payments; no time frame stated
Source · Our page
A flagged charge’s payout is released 14 days after the notice if you do nothing
Source · Our page
Funds usually held for up to 21 days
Source · Our page
Reserve rulesAccounts with a reserve are reviewed after a minimum of six months
Source · Our page
Set at the processor’s discretion, funded on 3 days’ notice; can be held 10 months after termination
Source · Our page
May require one “for any reason” in its sole reasonable discretion; can be raised, reduced or removed at any time
Source · Our page
Fixed or rolling; the amount or percentage and the period are emailed to you
Source · Our page
Rolling, minimum or jumpstart; reviewed within every 180 days
Source · Our page

Chargeback fees and response windows

What a dispute costs before anyone decides who is right, and how long you have to answer.

PolicySquareCloverToastStripePayPal
Chargeback feeNone: Square says there are no fees for its dispute management
Source · Our page
Not published on the pages we read
Source · Our page
$15 per chargeback notice, charged win or lose
Source · Our page
$15 per dispute, plus $15 if you contest it (returned if you win)
Source · Our page
$20 per card chargeback; $15 standard dispute fee on PayPal checkout payments
Source · Our page
Time to respond7 days
Source · Our page
Set by each dispute’s reason code; no single number published
Source · Our page
15 calendar days
Source · Our page
Usually 7 to 21 days, by card network
Source · Our page
10 days to respond to a claim
Source · Our page

Contracts, hardware and data

What it takes to walk away: the contract, the equipment and the customer records.

PolicySquareCloverToastStripePayPal
Contract and early terminationNo contract term or early termination fee stated in the Payment Terms; a closed account cannot be reactivated
Source 1 · Source 2 · Our page
Three-year initial term, then one-year automatic extensions; written notice 30 days before the term ends. Fee amount not published
Source · Our page
One-year automatic renewals unless you give 30 days’ written notice; early exit costs the remaining software fees, or $150 for each month left on pay-as-you-go
Source · Our page
You can end the agreement at any time by closing the account in the Dashboard; no setup or monthly fees listed
Source 1 · Source 2 · Our page
Close any time in Settings once the balance is out; not possible with a limitation, and a closed account cannot be reopened
Source · Our page
Hardware lock-inReturns within 30 days of delivery; the policy describes no lease or lock-in period
Source · Our page
Devices sold upfront or on 36-month plans; terms warn they may not work with another processor, and an unreturned rental costs the greater of $250 or fair market value
Source 1 · Source 2 · Our page
Easy Pay is a lease of 180, 360 or 540 days and Toast owns the hardware meanwhile; unused hardware returns within 90 days of shipment
Source 1 · Source 2 · Our page
Readers sold outright (Reader M2 $59, Reader S710 $299); no return window on the pages we read
Source · Our page
Returns within 30 days of delivery, you pay shipping; Apple products cannot be returned for a refund
Source · Our page
Export of customers and saved cardsExport the Customer Directory before closing; saved cards go only to a PCI DSS Level 1 processor, in up to two weeks
Source 1 · Source 2 · Our page
Customer list as a CSV from the web dashboard, not the device; saved card export not published
Source · Our page
You own your Merchant Data; nightly exports need Customer Care to switch on; ask within 30 days of termination. Saved card export not published
Source 1 · Source 2 · Our page
Encrypted file of customers, cards, emails and metadata, sent only to a PCI DSS Level 1 processor
Source · Our page
Not published on the pages we read
Our page

Rates are the standard published US rates as listed on November 11, 2026. Your own agreement, plan or negotiated pricing can differ. “Our page” links go to the MazalPOS page with the full detail for that processor.

What changed since November 8

Our 54 processor pages were written from these same sources on November 8, 2026. Re-opening them on November 11, 2026 turned up these differences, and the tables use today’s version:

  • Clover now lists card rates on its retail pricing page: 2.6% + 10¢ or 2.3% + 10¢ in person, 3.5% + 10¢ typed in, and 1.75% for Rapid Deposit. Our earlier page said only that the processor or bank sets the rate.
  • Stripe’s pricing page lists a $15 dispute countered fee on top of the $15 dispute received fee, returned if you win.
  • PayPal’s fee page lists a $15 standard dispute fee for PayPal checkout payments next to the $20 card chargeback fee, and 1.50% with a 50 cent minimum for Instant Transfer.
  • PayPal’s short help article on reserves now names two types, rolling and minimum, while its longer business article still names three, adding jumpstart.
  • We could not re-confirm the wording on Clover’s pricing page about termination fees, so the table gives Clover’s contract terms and says the fee amount is not published.

How we built this report

We started from the 54 MazalPOS processor problem pages, each written from Square, Clover, Toast, Stripe or PayPal’s own help, pricing and legal pages. For this report we re-opened every page cited in the tables on November 11, 2026 (38 pages in all) and kept a fact only if the page still said it. Where a number was new or different, we used the one on the page today and listed it above.

  • Scope: published US policy for small businesses. Negotiated rates, other countries and partner or reseller contracts are out of scope.
  • Clover sells through banks and resellers. The contract and reserve cells quote Clover’s published terms for Citibank-sponsored accounts; other Clover agreements can differ.
  • “Not published” means we did not find the figure on the processor’s own pages on the date checked. It does not mean the fee or rule does not exist.
  • This is public policy, not data from any store’s account and not data from MazalPOS customers. We did not rank the processors, and none of them reviewed this report before publication.
  • Money examples use the listed base rate only, before any monthly plan fee, add-on or currency charge.

Download the data and cite it

Download the full table as a CSV (55 rows: theme, policy, processor, finding, published or not, source URLs, our detail page and the date checked).

Cite this report: MazalPOS, “2026 Payment Processor Report: holds, reserves, fees and how hard it is to leave,” published November 11, 2026, https://mazalpos.com/journal/payment-processor-report-2026/. You may quote the findings and tables with a link to this page.

Every processor page behind the data

Each processor has its own set of plain-English pages with the steps, tables and sources in full. Start from all processor problems, or go straight to one:

Square

Clover

Toast

Stripe

PayPal

Where MazalPOS fits

MazalPOS makes point of sale software for stores with staff: a register on iPad and any computer that keeps selling offline, an online store on the same inventory, and the MazalTeam staff app. It takes cards, cash and pay links, with a 3% fee on pay links. Card payments on MazalPOS run through each store’s own Stripe account, so Stripe is one of the five processors in this report; we used the same method for all five. Moving your data from your old POS is free, and there is a 14-day trial with no card. See payments and how to switch without losing data.

Common questions

Of the five we checked on November 11, 2026, Toast lists $15 per chargeback notice, charged win or lose, Stripe lists $15 per dispute plus $15 more to contest it, and PayPal lists $20 per card chargeback. Square says it charges no dispute management fee. Clover’s pages we read do not list an amount.

Stripe and PayPal both list 1.5% with a 50 cent minimum. Clover and Toast list 1.75%, and Square lists 1.95% per instant or same-day transfer.

Clover’s published terms set a three-year initial term with one-year automatic extensions, and Toast’s Merchant Agreement renews for one year at a time with an early termination fee. Square’s Payment Terms state no term or early termination fee, Stripe lets you close at any time, and PayPal lets you close once your balance is out and nothing is unresolved.

Square and Stripe publish a process: each sends saved cards only to a PCI DSS Level 1 processor, and Square says it takes up to two weeks. Clover, Toast and PayPal do not publish a saved card export on the pages we read, so ask before you sign.

We re-opened every source page on November 11, 2026 and kept only what the page still said. It covers public US policy, not any store’s account or MazalPOS customer data. You can download the full table as a CSV and quote it with a link to this page.

Written by Mike Akop, founder of MazalPOS. We build and support the register, online store and staff app that stores from Las Vegas to Honolulu run on. Questions about this guide? Talk to a real person.

Not sure where to start?

Talk to a real
person today.

Tell us how your store works and we will show you MazalPOS with your own products.

14 days free. No card. Cancel anytime.