On this page
In short
- Dispute within 15 calendar days of the report date, or it is ruled for the cardholder automatically.
- Toast lists a $15 processing fee per notification, win or lose.
- Some reason codes can bring a card network fee of up to $500 if you dispute and lose.
- A dispute cannot be edited after you submit it, so upload everything first.
What happens when a chargeback lands
Toast's help page defines a chargeback as a forced reversal of funds that starts when a cardholder complains to their card issuer. Toast says the amount is debited from your bank account within two to four calendar days after it receives the notice, and it is taken automatically from that day's deposit. Notices and receipts are also stored in Toast Web. A retrieval request is not a chargeback; it only asks for more information. You must dispute to have a chance of getting the money back. The notice goes to the financial contacts in your communication preferences and also to owners and general managers.
Toast also says it only relays information between you and the issuing bank. After you submit documents in the Chargeback Challenger, the issuing bank alone decides, and Toast is not told the reasoning. Toast Customer Care can guide you but cannot contact the bank or speed it up.
| Step | What Toast says |
|---|---|
| Notice | Sent to finance contacts, owners and general managers |
| Money taken | Debited within two to four calendar days, usually from that day's deposit |
| Deadline | 15 calendar days from the notification report date |
| Evidence | JPG, PDF, PNG or TIFF files plus an explanation |
| Bank review | Can take up to 180 days; winners are paid by end of month |
The deadline and the fees
You have 15 calendar days from the report date, which is the day Toast receives the notice. Miss it and the dispute is automatically ruled in the cardholder's favor and the funds are not returned. Check the Chargeback Challenger dashboard often, because emails can get lost.
Toast lists a $15 fee to process each chargeback notification, charged whether or not you dispute and even if you win. It says the fee is not waived unless the chargeback came from a known Toast processing outage or another Toast issue. Toast also warns that card networks may charge up to $500 for disputing chargebacks they treat as nearly indisputable. For Mastercard it names reason codes 4808 (authorization related), 4870 (chip liability shift) and 4871 (chip and PIN liability shift). Amex is different: Toast says it has no arbitration process.
Building a stronger dispute
Toast says to open the chargeback, write an explanation, upload supporting documents and submit before the deadline. Files can be JPG, PDF, PNG or TIFF. Once submitted, nothing can be added, so gather the signed receipt, itemized receipts, proof of service or delivery and messages with the customer first. For a duplicate processing claim, Toast says to find every transaction paid with that card and include the itemized receipts. Toast also has an AI helper that drafts an explanation, but says it is only a starting point and you must check it.
If the bank rules for you, the report may show the reversal as temporary, because the cardholder can continue to dispute.
Withholding and excessive chargebacks
The Payment Processing Terms say Toast may deduct a chargeback and its fees from your account, any proceeds due or a reserve, may delay payouts while chargebacks are pending, and may withhold the amount of a chargeback it reasonably believes is likely. If Toast decides your chargebacks are excessive, it may add fees, a reserve, delayed payouts or termination. See reserves and funds on hold.
Example
Example: a jewelry store gets a $900 chargeback notice on the 1st. About $900 comes out of a deposit by the 5th, plus the $15 fee. The owner has until the 16th to dispute. If the bank rules for the store, Toast says the funds return by end of month. The fee stays.
How a second way to take cards helps
MazalPOS has a chargeback lookup, and the manager app shows chargebacks alongside Stripe payouts, so the sale behind a dispute is quick to find. Payments run through your own Stripe account, which has its own dispute rules and fees. Our chargeback glossary page explains the terms.
Common questions
Toast says 15 calendar days from the notification report date. After that it is automatically ruled for the cardholder.
Yes. Toast says the fee covers processing the notice and applies regardless of the outcome, unless a Toast outage or issue caused it.
No. Toast says the cardholder's issuing bank is the sole decision maker and Toast cannot influence its decision or timing.
No. Toast says a submitted dispute cannot be edited or amended. If you have critical new evidence, contact Customer Care.
Sources
Checked on 2026-11-08. Rules and prices change, so confirm on the official page before you act.
Related
Toast declined card payments: what you can and cannot do
Written by Mike Akop, founder of MazalPOS. We build and support the register, online store and staff app that stores from Las Vegas to Honolulu run on. Questions? Talk to a real person.
