Retail stores · Sell online

Retail: selling online without overselling in store

Two stock lists mean two ways to be wrong. This is how a store with staff sells in person and online from a single count.

By Mike Akop, founderUpdated 7 min read

On this page
  1. The real problem with selling online from a store
  2. One catalog and one count is the whole fix
  3. Worked example: a sporting goods shop
  4. Mistakes that cost retailers online
  5. How to start selling online without a second job
  6. Why local pickup matters for a store
  7. Returns and payments on web orders
  8. How MazalPOS handles selling online for retail stores
  9. Common questions

In short

  • Run the register and the website from one catalog and one stock count.
  • Start with your best 50 to 100 sellers, not the whole catalog.
  • Offer in-store pickup alongside shipping for local customers.
  • Write a clear return policy and keep delivery records for every parcel.

The real problem with selling online from a store

Most retail owners start the website the same way: someone builds a store page, uploads 300 products, and the shop now has two stock counts. One lives in the register, one lives in the website. For a week it works. Then a customer buys the last denim jacket in the store at 2 p.m., another buys the same jacket online at 2:10 p.m., and now you owe somebody an apology and a refund.

That is overselling, and it hurts more online because the customer cannot see the shelf. They paid, they got a confirmation email, they expect a box. A cancellation after the fact reads as a broken promise, and shoppers who are canceled on rarely come back.

The second problem is the time spent. Someone has to retype every new arrival into the website, update prices on both sides, and answer the question "is this in the store?" by walking to the rack. When you have a staff of four and a store to run, that job lands at the end of the day and gets skipped.

One catalog and one count is the whole fix

The only reliable cure is to stop keeping two lists. The register and the website should read the same products and the same stock count. When a sale happens in either place, one number drops, and the other side sees it right away.

That also means one set of prices, one set of photos, one set of sizes. If you mark a jacket down for a weekend sale, you change it once. If you retire a style, it disappears from both places together. The goal is that your website is just another register, open all day, that happens to sit in a customer's pocket.

For a deeper look at the setup, the guide on selling online and in store from one inventory walks through it step by step.

Worked example: a sporting goods shop

An example with invented numbers. A sporting goods store sells 60 pairs of trail running shoes a month in store at $120. The owner opens a website and sells 25 more a month at $120 online, with shipping charged separately.

  • In-store revenue on shoes: 60 x $120 = $7,200.
  • Online revenue on shoes: 25 x $120 = $3,000.
  • Cost per pair: $66, so total cost on 85 pairs = $5,610.
  • Gross profit before fees: $10,200 minus $5,610 = $4,590.
  • Card fees online at an assumed 2.9% plus 30 cents: about $87 + $7.50 per 25 orders, near $94.50 in total on the $3,000.

The extra 25 sales add $3,000 in revenue and roughly $1,350 in gross profit after cost, minus about $95 in card fees. That is real money, but only if no sale is lost to a wrong count. If the shop's size 10 sells out in the store on Saturday and the website still shows two, those two online orders are canceled. Do that six times a year and you lose more in refunds, time and goodwill than the shipping income covered.

Mistakes that cost retailers online

  • Importing the catalog once and never again. New arrivals go on the floor but not on the site, so the website looks like last season.
  • Keeping a hidden reserve for the site. Some owners set aside five units for web, which strands stock that could sell at the counter.
  • No clear pickup option. Many local shoppers would rather order online and pick up the same day. Without it you lose the shipping-averse customer.
  • Sending web orders to a separate list. If online orders arrive in a different inbox than register sales, they get packed late or missed.
  • Shipping everything at one flat rate. A $9 candle and a $140 lamp should not cost you the same to send.

How to start selling online without a second job

  1. Pick your 50 to 100 best sellers first. They have the best photos and the highest turnover.
  2. Make sure every one is counted as a SKU with correct sizes and colors, then fix the stock count before you publish.
  3. Offer both shipping and in-store pickup, so a local customer gets it the same day for no shipping cost.
  4. Decide who packs web orders and when. A 3 p.m. cutoff with a named person works better than "whoever has time."
  5. Set low-stock alerts so online bestsellers do not run out unnoticed.
  6. Watch your first month of sales by channel and add the next batch of products once the routine holds.

Your inventory habits matter even more online; see retail inventory with staff for the weekly routine.

Why local pickup matters for a store

A retail store has something a pure web shop does not: a building ten minutes from the customer. Offering pickup turns that into an advantage. A shopper checks the website at lunch, sees that the trail shoes are in size 10, reserves them, and walks in at 5:30. No shipping charge, no waiting three days, and a good chance they add socks or a water bottle at the counter.

Pickup also protects your margin. Shipping a pair of $120 shoes can cost you $9 to $14 in postage and packaging, and a size exchange doubles that. A pickup order costs a few minutes of a cashier's time. Put pickup orders on a shelf behind the counter with the customer's name, and tell staff who checks them out so the handoff is quick.

Staff matter here. If your weekend crew does not know where pickup orders live, the customer waits while three people look. A single labeled shelf and one daily check of the order list prevents most of that.

Returns and payments on web orders

Online returns cost you real money. You pay the return shipping, you wait for the parcel, and the item sits in limbo for a week. Write your policy in plain words on the site: how many days, who pays shipping, whether you give store credit or a refund to the original card. Customers who read a clear policy rarely argue with it.

Web orders are also more exposed to disputes, because the customer is not in front of you. Keep tracking numbers and a delivery record for every parcel. If a buyer later claims the box never came, that record is your evidence. For the dispute side, read retail chargebacks.

How MazalPOS handles selling online for retail stores

MazalPOS runs an online store on the same catalog and the same live stock count as the register and every location, so you do not sell what is already gone. Customers can choose shipping or in-store pickup, and web orders show up in the same order list as register sales. Refunds can be done from the register, the manager's phone or the back office. Moving your catalog from another system includes a free data move, and the 14-day trial needs no card.

Common questions

Yes, if the website uses your register's catalog and stock. Then the only new job is packing orders, which one person can do in a set daily window.

Use one stock count shared by both. A sale in either place lowers the same number, so the website stops showing an item when the last one is gone.

Start with your best sellers that photograph well, then add more once your daily routine works. A small clean site beats a large unreliable one.

State a window, who pays return shipping and whether you refund or give store credit. Write it on the site before the first order ships.

Yes. It sells from the same catalog and live stock as the register, with shipping or in-store pickup and web orders in the same list.

Words on this page

OversellingStock countSKULow-stock alert

Want the full guide? Read How to Sell Online and In Store From One Inventory.

Written by Mike Akop, founder of MazalPOS. We build and support the register, online store and staff app that stores from Las Vegas to Honolulu run on. Questions about this guide? Talk to a real person.

Not sure where to start?

Talk to a real
person today.

Tell us how your store works and we will show you MazalPOS with your own products.

14 days free. No card. Cancel anytime.