On this page
In short
- Overselling happens when two systems each think they still have the item.
- It is most common when a shop sells in person and online from separate counts.
- Each oversold order costs a refund, an apology and sometimes a bad review.
- One shared live count is the best fix; reserves and alerts help as a backup.
How overselling happens
Picture a boutique with one pair of gold hoop earrings left. A customer in the store picks them up and pays at 2:00 PM. At 2:03 PM, a shopper on the website adds the same pair to a cart and pays. The website still said "1 in stock." You now owe two people the same pair, and you have one.
The root cause is almost always two counts that do not talk to each other. One count lives in the register. Another lives in the online store. Someone updates one by hand, or a nightly import updates it, and in the gap between updates the counts disagree. Any sale in that gap can be oversold.
A second cause is a count that is simply wrong: the system says 3, the shelf holds 1, and nobody has noticed. That is shrinkage or a counting mistake, and it turns into overselling as soon as someone sells the phantom items.
A third cause is timing between locations. Item sold at shop A, still showing available at shop B until the transfer or the sync catches up.
Common kinds of overselling
It helps to name the pattern, because each has a different fix.
- Channel gap: in-store versus online, the most common one.
- Location gap: one location sells something the system says another location still has.
- Sync delay: the count is right, but it updates in batches, so fast-selling items slip through.
- Wrong count: bad data from a missed delivery, a miskeyed receiving or theft.
- Variant mix-up: a size or color sells from the wrong variant or the wrong SKU.
A worked example
This is an example. A skin care shop sells a $64 serum online and in the store. A busy weekend brings 40 units of demand against 36 units on hand, with the counts out of step by a few hours.
Say 4 online orders come in for units already sold in the store. The shop now owes four customers a $64 serum it cannot ship.
- Refunds: 4 x $64 = $256 returned
- Shipping labels and packing time already spent: about 4 x $6 = $24
- Payment fees that may not come back on a refund: depends on your processor; say $8 across the four
- Discount codes to say sorry: 4 x $10 = $40
The total is about $328 for one weekend, plus four unhappy customers. The real damage is often reviews and lost repeat buyers, which are harder to count. Fixing the count once is far cheaper than paying this each busy weekend.
Where it usually goes wrong
- Keeping separate stock counts for the store and the website. This is the main source of the problem.
- Updating online stock by hand on a schedule. Whatever sells between updates is at risk.
- Not counting the shelf. If the system says 12 but the shelf has 9, you have three phantom sales waiting. See stock count.
- Ignoring returns and damaged goods. A damaged item still on the count can be sold twice.
- Waiting for the customer to notice. Cancel and refund fast, with a note and a small thank-you, before the complaint arrives.
Tips for owners
Run store and online from one live count. If that is not possible, keep a small buffer: show 1 less than you have for items that sell fast, or hide the item online when it hits 2.
Set a low-stock alert on your best sellers, so you reorder before the shelf is empty.
Count your top 20 items every week. A short count of fast movers catches the biggest risks.
When you must cancel, message the same day, refund in full and offer to notify the customer when it is back. Most people forgive a quick, honest message.
How MazalPOS handles overselling
MazalPOS keeps one live stock count shared by the register, the online store and every location, so you do not sell what is already gone. The online store runs on the same catalog and stock, and web orders land in the same order list as in-store sales. Low-stock alerts, transfers between locations, counting stock from your phone and receiving stock from a photo of the supplier invoice help keep that count right.
Common questions
No. Backordering is a planned sale of an item you will have later, and the customer knows. Overselling is an accident.
Yes, if you sell online and in the store from separate counts, or if the count is wrong.
Count your fast sellers, hide low items online, and move to one shared stock count.
It uses one live count shared by the register, online store and all locations, which removes the main cause.
Related terms
Want the full guide? Read How to Sell Online and In Store From One Inventory.
Written by Mike Akop, founder of MazalPOS. We build and support the register, online store and staff app that stores from Las Vegas to Honolulu run on. Questions about this term? Talk to a real person.
