On this page
In short
- Pay on net sales so returns and discounts are already taken out.
- Decide whether a goal rate covers the whole day or only the part above it.
- Write the rule for shared sales and returns before the first dispute.
- Show staff their numbers during the week, not only at payday.
Why commissions on the sales floor get messy
In a clothing store, a furniture showroom or an electronics counter, the person who greets the customer is often not the person who rings the sale. A floor associate shows three couches, a manager closes the deal, and the cashier who walks the customer to the register gets credit in the system. Whoever's login is on the receipt gets paid, and the others feel cheated.
Retail also has more moving parts than a service business. Returns come back two weeks later. A discount is applied by a manager. A gift card is sold, and nobody agrees whether that counts. Each of these raises one question: whose commission changes, and by how much? When the answer lives in a spreadsheet at month end, arguments follow.
Done well, commission plans make your best sellers stay and push everyone toward the products that make you money. Done badly, they cause staff to steal each other's customers, push returns on someone else, or quit after one disputed paycheck. Retail already has high turnover, so a pay system that people trust is worth real effort.
The plans retail stores actually use
Most stores land on one of a few structures. A flat percentage, say 4% of net sales, is the simplest and the easiest to explain. A tiered commission raises the rate as a person passes a goal: 3% up to $800 in a day, 5% once they pass it. A base hourly wage plus commission is common where the floor needs steady coverage. Some stores pay a spiff, a fixed bonus of $10 to $25, for pushing a specific product like a protection plan or an overstock item.
Whatever you pick, define "sales" on paper. Net sales after discounts and returns is cleaner than gross, because it stops people from earning commission on a sale the customer gave back. If part of the day's commission depends on reaching a goal, say clearly whether the higher rate applies only to sales above the goal or to the whole day. The second feels better to staff and is easier to read on a receipt.
The guide on retail commission plans compares them in more detail, and the entry on retail commission covers the basics.
Worked example: a mattress and furniture showroom
An example with invented numbers. Dana sells furniture on a 3% commission up to a $1,500 day and 5% on the whole day once she hits $1,500 in net sales.
- Monday: $1,200 net sales. She missed the goal, so 3% x $1,200 = $36.
- Saturday: $2,400 net sales. She hit the goal, so 5% x $2,400 = $120.
If the higher rate applied only above the goal, Saturday would pay 3% x $1,500 = $45 plus 5% x $900 = $45, or $90. The whole-day rule pays $30 more, which is the kind of reward that makes a person stay late on a busy Saturday.
Now add a split. Dana and Marcus both worked a $3,000 sectional sale, 60/40. Dana's credit is $1,800, Marcus's is $1,200. If the customer returns a $600 chair two weeks later, you reverse commission on that return at the rate of the day it was earned, and split it the same way. The rule is only fair if everyone sees it written before the sale happens.
Commission mistakes in retail
- Paying on gross sales. A $900 sale that comes back as a full refund still paid the associate, and you cannot easily claw it back.
- No rule for returns. Without a policy, returns hit the manager's numbers or nobody's, and staff learn to avoid processing them.
- Losing the team sale. One person gets all the credit for a deal three people worked, and the other two stop helping.
- Paying a commission that overrides minimum wage rules. Federal law sets a minimum wage and overtime for most hourly staff, and commissioned retail staff can be exempt only under a narrow set of conditions. State rules differ, so check yours before designing a plan.
- Doing the math by hand. A manager who spends two Sundays a month on commission sheets will make mistakes, and a single wrong paycheck costs you more than the time saved.
How to set up a plan your staff trust
- Pick one measure: net sales, gross margin or units. Net sales is the easiest to explain on the floor.
- Write the rate, the goal, and whether the higher rate covers the whole day.
- Decide in advance how returns, exchanges, gift card sales and manager discounts are treated.
- Decide how a shared sale splits, and how the split is recorded at the register, not afterwards.
- Pay on a regular schedule, such as the 1st to the 15th and the 16th to month end, so people know when the money lands. The glossary entry on pay period explains the options.
- Show staff their own numbers during the week, so the paycheck is never a surprise.
You will also need to schedule coverage so commissioned staff are on the floor when traffic peaks; see retail staff schedules.
Handling disputes and bad weeks
Two situations come up in nearly every retail store. The first is a disputed sale, where two people claim the same customer. Decide a tiebreak rule ahead of time, such as the first person to greet the customer or a standard 50/50 split, and apply it the same way every time. Hold the commission on a contested sale until the manager rules, and tell both people the decision and the reason.
The second is a slow week where someone ends below their base, or where returns exceed sales and the commission turns negative. Decide whether the negative amount carries over to the next pay period or is dropped. Carrying it over fairly, instead of taking it out of one check, keeps people from quitting after a bad return week. Whichever rule you pick, put it on one page and give everyone a copy.
One more habit helps in a busy store: review the week's commission numbers every Monday for ten minutes. Look for sales with a very large discount, returns clustered under one name, and days where the credited person was not even clocked in. Most of these are honest mistakes, and catching them in a week is far easier than untangling them at month end.
How MazalPOS handles commissions for retail stores
MazalPOS works out commissions and payroll totals automatically from sales. It supports goal-based rates where the rate reached applies to the whole day, a sale split by percent between two people, commission holds on disputed sales, and fair carry-over of negative pay. Pay periods run semi-monthly, the 1st to the 15th and the 16th to month end. Staff see their sales and commission in the MazalTeam app. MazalPOS produces hours and commission totals, but it does not file payroll taxes. Moving from another system includes a free data move, and the 14-day trial needs no card.
Common questions
It depends on the product and the margin, so there is no single answer. Stores with high-ticket goods often pay a few percent of net sales, and stores with thin margins pay less or use a spiff on certain items.
Net is cleaner. It already removes discounts and returns, so you do not pay for a sale the customer gave back.
Agree a percent split at the time of the sale, such as 60/40, and record it on the sale. Applying it afterwards invites arguments.
Reverse the commission at the rate it was earned, split the same way as the original sale. Write the rule down so it is the same for everyone.
MazalPOS calculates hours and commission totals from sales and time clock data, but it does not file payroll taxes.
Words on this page
Retail commissionTiered commissionCommission splitPay period
Want the full guide? Read Retail Commission Plans: Flat Rate, Tiers and Sales Goals.
Written by Mike Akop, founder of MazalPOS. We build and support the register, online store and staff app that stores from Las Vegas to Honolulu run on. Questions about this guide? Talk to a real person.
