Choosing a POS

Vagaro vs Square for a Salon or Spa With Staff: Prices, Fees and Fit

Both book appointments and take cards. The difference shows up in the bill once you have a team, so here are the numbers from each company's own pages.

By Mike Akop, founderPublished 6 min read

The MazalPOS register on an iPad next to the MazalTeam app showing an employee's hours, sales and commission
On this page
  1. Which is cheaper, Vagaro or Square?
  2. How does the price change as I add staff?
  3. What are the card processing fees on Vagaro and Square?
  4. Is the Vagaro card reader really free?
  5. Do Vagaro or Square lock me into a contract?
  6. Which is better for no-shows and cancellations?
  7. Which one pays my staff and works out commission?
  8. Which is better if my salon or spa sells a lot of retail?
  9. Is there an option built for spas and salons that sell retail and pay commission?
  10. How do I switch from Vagaro or Square without losing data?
  11. Questions to ask before you buy
  12. Common questions

Key takeaways

  • Square Appointments starts at $0 and charges Plus at $49 a month per location, with no charge per staff calendar.
  • Vagaro starts at $30 a month and adds $10 per calendar, up to $90 for 7 or more.
  • Square publishes its card rates; Vagaro's pricing page does not, so get it in writing.
  • Vagaro's free reader has a $150 fee if you stop processing within 12 months.
  • For retail-heavy spas and salons that pay commission, MazalPOS is $99 a month per location with no per-user fee.

Vagaro vs Square comes down to team size and how you are paid: Square Appointments is cheaper for a growing team because its free plan has unlimited staff calendars and its paid plans are priced per location, while Vagaro charges $30 a month for one calendar and more for each person you add. Square publishes its card rates and Vagaro's pricing page does not, and Vagaro's free reader comes with a 12 month processing commitment. Every price below was checked on each company's own page on November 13, 2026.

Which is cheaper, Vagaro or Square?

Square is cheaper for a small team, because Square Appointments has a free plan and its paid plans are priced per location, while Vagaro charges more for each extra calendar. Vagaro costs $30 a month for one person (an intro rate of $23.99 for the first 6 months, per its pricing page on November 13, 2026). Square Appointments Free is $0 a month, Square Plus is $49 a month per location and Square Premium is $149 a month per location.

SystemStarting priceWith 5 staffFree trial
Vagaro$30 monthly, one calendar$70 monthly ($63.99 for the first 6 months)Offered, length not listed
Square Appointments$0 on Free$0 on Free, $49 on Plus, per location30 days on Plus
MazalPOS$99 per location monthly$99 per location, no per-user fee14 days, no card

Card processing comes on top of every plan in this table.

How does the price change as I add staff?

Vagaro's price rises with each calendar you add, and Square's does not. On Vagaro's own price picker, 2 people cost $40 a month, 3 cost $50, 4 cost $60, 5 cost $70, 6 cost $80, and 7 or more cost $90. Square lists unlimited staff calendars on its free Appointments plan and charges Plus and Premium per location, so a team of eight pays the same plan price as a team of two.

What are the card processing fees on Vagaro and Square?

Square publishes its card rates by plan, and Vagaro's pricing page does not show its rate, so ask Vagaro for it in writing before you sign. Square's in-person rate is 2.6% + 15¢ on Free, 2.5% + 15¢ on Plus and 2.4% + 15¢ on Premium. Online payments are 3.3% + 30¢ on Free and 2.9% + 30¢ on Plus and Premium. On a $100 service paid in person, that is $2.75 on Square Free and $2.65 on Plus. Our card fee calculator runs your own monthly sales through any rate.

Is the Vagaro card reader really free?

The Vagaro reader is free only if you keep processing with Vagaro Merchant Services for 12 months. Vagaro's pricing page says a merchant who stops processing before 12 months agrees to pay a $150 early cancellation fee. Square sells its hardware outright, with options starting at $59, and lists a 1 year warranty on most of it (see Square hardware returns and warranty).

Do Vagaro or Square lock me into a contract?

Neither asks for a long software contract, but the details differ. Vagaro's pricing page says you can cancel anytime with no cancellation fees, with "exclusions apply" printed under it, and the reader terms above are the main exclusion to read. Square Plus and Premium start with a 30 day free trial and you can move between plans. Read what to check in a salon software contract before you sign either one.

Which is better for no-shows and cancellations?

Both handle it, but on Square you need the paid Plus plan. Square lists cancellation policy and no-show fees, multi-staff booking and a waitlist as Plus features, not Free ones. Vagaro lists customer waitlist options, memberships, packages and gift certificates in its plan. If no-shows cost you money every week, compare the deposit rules side by side; our page on salon and spa deposits shows what to look for.

Which one pays my staff and works out commission?

Square Payroll is a separate product at $35 a month plus $6 per person paid, per Square's pricing page, and Vagaro's pricing page does not show payroll as part of its plan, so ask whether it is an add-on. If your team is paid commission on services and retail, check whether the system works out each person's commission for you or only exports sales for you to add up. In MazalPOS, commission is worked out on every sale and payroll adds itself up each pay period, the 1st to the 15th and the 16th to the end of the month. See how to pay commissions at a spa or salon.

Which is better if my salon or spa sells a lot of retail?

Both list inventory tracking, but both are built around the appointment book first, so test the retail side with your real products. Ask how each one counts stock for every shade and size, warns you when stock runs low, and keeps the count the same in the store and on your website. A salon or spa that sells hundreds of products is often better served by a POS built around retail and staff pay. See selling online and in store from one inventory.

Is there an option built for spas and salons that sell retail and pay commission?

Yes, MazalPOS is built for retail stores with staff, including spas and salons. The register runs on iPad or any computer and keeps selling offline. Staff use the MazalTeam phone app to clock in and see their hours, sales, commissions and schedules. When an employee reaches a goal, the rate reached applies to their whole day. Essentials is $99 a month per location and Growth is $169 a month per location with the online store, payroll and commissions, and there is no per-user fee. Compare the full detail on MazalPOS vs Vagaro and MazalPOS vs Square.

How do I switch from Vagaro or Square without losing data?

Export your clients, products and sales history before you cancel, and keep the old account open until the new one shows the same numbers. MazalPOS moves customers, products, staff, sales history, hours and payroll from your old POS for free, and set-up takes one day. Our guide to switching POS systems without losing data lists every check, and exporting your data from Square covers the Square side.

Questions to ask before you buy

  • What will I pay a month with my whole team on it, today and after any intro price?
  • What is my card rate in person and online, in writing?
  • Is the card reader mine, or tied to a processing commitment?
  • Are no-show fees and deposits on the plan I am buying?
  • Does the system work out commission, or only export sales?
  • Does retail stock stay the same in the store and online?
  • Can I export my clients and sales history if I leave?

Common questions

Square is cheaper for a small team because Square Appointments has a free plan and charges per location, not per calendar. Vagaro starts at $30 a month for one calendar and adds $10 for each extra one, up to $90 for 7 or more.

Vagaro lists $30 a month for one calendar, rising to $90 a month for 7 or more, with lower intro prices for the first 6 months, checked November 13, 2026 on its pricing page.

Square Appointments Free is $0, Plus is $49 a month per location and Premium is $149 a month per location, plus card fees from 2.4% + 15 cents in person.

Vagaro says you can cancel anytime with no cancellation fees, but its free card reader carries a $150 early cancellation fee if you stop processing with Vagaro Merchant Services before 12 months.

Written by Mike Akop, founder of MazalPOS. We build and support the register, online store and staff app that stores from Las Vegas to Honolulu run on. Questions about this guide? Talk to a real person.

Not sure where to start?

Talk to a real
person today.

Tell us how your store works and we will show you MazalPOS with your own products.

14 days free. No card. Cancel anytime.