Choosing a POS

Best Shopify POS Alternatives for In-Store Retailers

Shopify POS is built around an online store, and a shop with a team pays for POS Pro on top of the plan. Here are the alternatives for stores that sell mostly in person, what each costs, and what you give up.

By Mike Akop, founderPublished 9 min read

The MazalPOS stock count on an iPad next to the MazalTeam app showing an employee’s shifts for the month
On this page
  1. What is the best Shopify POS alternative for an in-store retailer?
  2. Why do in-store retailers look for a Shopify POS alternative?
  3. How do the Shopify POS alternatives compare on price?
  4. Which Shopify POS alternatives include staff scheduling, commissions and payroll?
  5. Why is MazalPOS the best Shopify POS alternative for a store with staff?
  6. Is Square a good Shopify POS alternative?
  7. Is Lightspeed Retail a good Shopify POS alternative?
  8. Is Clover a good Shopify POS alternative?
  9. What happens to my Shopify plan and hardware when I switch?
  10. How do I move my data out of Shopify POS?
  11. Which Shopify POS alternative fits which store?
  12. Common questions

Key takeaways

  • Shopify POS starts with a Shopify plan ($39, $105 or $399 a month) and adds POS Pro at $89 a month per location, billed yearly, for unlimited staff and full inventory tools.
  • Scheduling and payroll in Shopify come from apps such as Sling and Gusto, each with its own fee.
  • MazalPOS is month to month at $99 or $169 per location, with schedules and a staff app on every plan, and payroll and commissions on Growth.
  • Square is the cheapest start ($0 plan); Lightspeed fits large catalogs; Clover fits stores that want the hardware in one monthly payment.

What is the best Shopify POS alternative for an in-store retailer?

The best Shopify POS alternative for an in-store retailer with staff is MazalPOS: the register, inventory, staff schedules and the MazalTeam app come in one plan from $99 a month per location, month to month, and Growth at $169 adds payroll, commissions and an online store on the same stock. Square is the best pick if you want a free plan, Lightspeed Retail if you run a large catalog with a lot of supplier ordering, and Clover if you want the terminal and software in one monthly payment.

How this list was made: MazalPOS publishes this guide and lists its own system first. Every competitor price below was read on that company’s own pricing page on November 16, 2026. Card processing and add-ons are extra unless we say so. Prices change, so check the live page before you sign.

Why do in-store retailers look for a Shopify POS alternative?

In-store retailers look for a Shopify POS alternative because Shopify charges for the store plan and the shop floor separately, and the team tools live in apps. Shopify’s plans are $39 Basic, $105 Grow and $399 Advanced a month, or $29, $79 and $299 a month paid yearly. Each retail location then adds POS Pro at $89 a month, which Shopify bills yearly.

  • Two bills for one shop. A store on Basic with POS Pro pays $39 + $89 = $128 a month for one location, before card fees and apps.
  • Limited staff on Basic. Shopify’s POS pricing page says limited staff can access the POS on Basic. Unlimited POS logins come with Grow, Advanced or POS Pro.
  • The useful retail tools are in POS Pro. Staff roles and permissions, inventory counts, purchase orders, low stock alerts and returns at any location are listed under POS Pro.
  • Team tools are apps. Shopify points to Sling for schedules, Gusto for payroll and EasyTeam for larger teams.
  • A fee for other processors. If you take cards through a provider other than Shopify Payments, Shopify lists a fee of 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced.

None of that matters much if your website is the main business. It matters a lot if most sales happen at the counter and you have a team on the floor.

How do the Shopify POS alternatives compare on price?

The Shopify POS alternatives compare most clearly on what one shop with a team pays each month. These are the software prices on each company’s own pricing page; hardware and card processing are separate unless noted.

SystemMonthly priceStaff schedulingPayroll
MazalPOS$99 Essentials, $169 Growth, per location, month to monthEvery plan, with the MazalTeam staff appHours and commission totals on Growth
Shopify POS$39 Basic, $105 Grow, $399 Advanced, plus POS Pro at $89 per location, billed yearlyThrough apps such as SlingThrough apps such as Gusto
Square for Retail$0 Free, $49 Plus, $149 Premium, per locationPlus and PremiumSquare Payroll from $35 a month + $6 per person paid
Lightspeed Retail$89 Basic, $149 Core, $289 Plus billed yearly, or $109, $179, $339 billed monthly, with Lightspeed PaymentsThrough Homebase, priced on requestThrough Homebase, US only, priced on request
Clover Retail$16, $180 or $240 a month for 36 months, hardware includedStandard and AdvancedPayroll integrations, an optional add-on

For one shop with five employees, Shopify Grow with POS Pro is $194 a month ($105 + $89) before a scheduling or payroll app. Square Plus with Square Payroll is $114 a month ($49 + $35 + 5 × $6). MazalPOS Growth is $169 with schedules, the staff app, commissions, payroll totals and the online store in the plan. How much does a POS system cost works through the same math for more systems.

Which Shopify POS alternatives include staff scheduling, commissions and payroll?

MazalPOS and Square include staff scheduling and commission tracking in the POS itself, Clover includes shift management on its bigger systems, and Shopify POS and Lightspeed send scheduling and payroll to partner apps.

  • MazalPOS: staff schedules and the MazalTeam app are on every plan. Growth adds commissions and payroll totals for each pay period.
  • Square: timecards, shift scheduling, time-off requests, tip pooling and commission tracking come with Plus and Premium, not Free. Square Payroll is a separate product from $35 a month plus $6 per person paid.
  • Shopify POS: staff permissions and unlimited POS logins come with POS Pro. For schedules and payroll, Shopify’s staff management page points to apps: Sling for schedules, Gusto for payroll and EasyTeam for larger teams, each with its own price.
  • Lightspeed Retail: scheduling, time tracking and payroll come through Homebase, which Lightspeed offers to its merchants at a price you get from its team. The payroll part is for US businesses only.
  • Clover: shift management is included on the Standard and Advanced retail systems, not Basic, and payroll integrations are an optional add-on. Commission tracking is not listed on Clover’s retail pricing page.

For a side-by-side list across more systems, read which POS systems include payroll and staff scheduling.

Why is MazalPOS the best Shopify POS alternative for a store with staff?

MazalPOS is the best Shopify POS alternative for a store with staff because the register, the stock count and the team tools are one plan priced per location, with no second subscription for the shop floor and no apps to add for schedules.

  • Price: Essentials is $99 a month per location: register, inventory, customers, reports, full staff scheduling, the MazalTeam app, and card and cash payments. Growth is $169 and adds the online store on the same inventory, payroll and commissions, and more than one location.
  • No per-employee fee. The price is per location, whether you have 3 people or 30.
  • The staff app. Every employee clocks in and sees their hours, sales, commission, schedule and time-off requests on their phone.
  • Commission on goals. When an employee reaches a goal, the reached rate applies to the whole day.
  • Payroll totals. Hours and commission add up for each pay period, the 1st to the 15th and the 16th to the end of the month. MazalPOS does not file payroll taxes.
  • Inventory built for a shop. One stock count for the register, the website and every location, with transfers between stores and low-stock alerts.
  • Offline-first. The register keeps selling when the internet drops.
  • 14 days free, no card, month to month.

Where Shopify wins: if your online store is the main business, or you sell on social media and marketplaces, Shopify’s online tools go further than ours. See MazalPOS vs Shopify POS side by side.

Is Square a good Shopify POS alternative?

Square is a good Shopify POS alternative if you want to start free and keep the team tools inside the POS. Square for Retail has a $0 Free plan, Plus at $49 and Premium at $149 a month per location, with in-person card rates of 2.6%, 2.5% and 2.4% + 15¢ by plan. Shift scheduling, timecards and commission tracking come with Plus and Premium. Square Payroll is extra, from $35 a month plus $6 per person paid, so the bill grows with every person on payroll. More in Square alternatives for stores with employees.

Is Lightspeed Retail a good Shopify POS alternative?

Lightspeed Retail is a good Shopify POS alternative for a store with a large catalog and a lot of ordering from suppliers. Lightspeed’s retail pricing page lists Basic at $89, Core at $149 and Plus at $289 a month billed yearly with Lightspeed Payments, or $109, $179 and $339 billed monthly, with one register included. Purchase orders and inventory tools are on every plan. Scheduling and payroll come through Homebase at a price Lightspeed quotes. If Lightspeed feels like more system than your shop needs, see the best Lightspeed alternatives for small retail stores.

Is Clover a good Shopify POS alternative?

Clover is a good Shopify POS alternative if you want the terminal, printer and software in one monthly payment and a 36-month term does not bother you. Clover’s retail systems are $16, $180 or $240 a month for 36 months with hardware included, or you buy the hardware up front: $349 for Basic, or $1,899 plus $84.95 a month for Standard. In-person card rates are 2.6% + 10¢ on Basic and 2.3% + 10¢ on Standard and Advanced. Compare the options in Clover alternatives for small retail stores.

What happens to my Shopify plan and hardware when I switch?

What happens to your Shopify plan and hardware depends on how you pay: Shopify plans can be paid monthly or yearly, POS Pro is billed yearly per location, and Shopify Plus runs on a 1- or 3-year term, so check what you have already paid for before you switch. Shopify POS runs on a phone or tablet with a Shopify card reader. MazalPOS runs on an iPad or a computer you already own, so the iPad at your counter can stay. Keep your Shopify account open until your exports are saved and checked.

How do I move my data out of Shopify POS?

You move your data out of Shopify POS by exporting your products and customers to CSV files from the Shopify admin, then importing them into the new system before your last day. Shopify’s Help Center says a product export downloads in your browser, or is emailed to you when any product has more than 100 variants. Customer profiles export to a CSV file too. With MazalPOS we move your customers, products, staff, sales history, hours and payroll for free, nothing goes live until the numbers match, and setup takes one day. How to switch POS systems without losing your data has the full checklist.

Which Shopify POS alternative fits which store?

Which Shopify POS alternative fits depends on where you sell and how big your team is.

  • A shop with staff that sells mostly in person: MazalPOS. Schedules, the staff app and inventory in one plan, with payroll and commissions on Growth.
  • One person and a tight budget: Square Free, then Plus once you need schedules.
  • A large catalog with constant supplier orders: Lightspeed Retail.
  • You want the hardware bundled in: Clover, if a 36-month term is fine.
  • Your website is the main business: stay on Shopify. Its online store and checkout are its strength, and in-person card rates start at 2.6% + 10¢ on Basic.

Common questions

For a store that sells mostly in person and has staff, MazalPOS: schedules and a staff app on every plan, commissions and payroll totals on Growth, month to month, from $99 a month per location. Square is the best free option.

Shopify’s POS pricing page lists Basic at $39, Grow at $105 and Advanced at $399 a month, plus POS Pro at $89 a month per location, billed yearly, for unlimited staff, staff roles and inventory tools. Card fees are extra.

No. Shopify’s staff management page points to apps for that: Sling for schedules, Gusto for payroll and EasyTeam for larger teams, each with its own price.

Yes. We move your customers, products, staff, sales history, hours and payroll for free, and setup takes one day.

Written by Mike Akop, founder of MazalPOS. We build and support the register, online store and staff app that stores from Las Vegas to Honolulu run on. Questions about this guide? Talk to a real person.

Not sure where to start?

Talk to a real
person today.

Tell us how your store works and we will show you MazalPOS with your own products.

14 days free. No card. Cancel anytime.