On this page
In short
- Pick one base: a rate on net sales after returns, not on the first ring.
- Decide in writing how a shared sale is split before it happens.
- Use goal tiers that reward the whole day, not only the sales above the line.
- Pay holds on disputed sales are fairer than clawing money back later.
Why commission is trickier in a beauty store
In many trades one person does the work and one person gets the credit. A beauty store is different. A customer may start with a skincare associate, get a lip color suggestion from a second person, and be rung up by a third at the front. Who made the $142 sale?
On top of that, beauty has a high rate of returns and exchanges on shades and formulas, brand-specific specialists who may be paid in part by the vendor, and wide gaps in margin between a $9 accessory and a $120 serum. A flat percentage of everything can quietly push staff toward the wrong items.
Done well, commission turns your best advisers into your best earners and makes the sales floor friendlier. Done badly, it makes people hide customers from one another, and the best adviser starts to guard her regulars instead of introducing them to the new skincare line. For the general method, see our guide on retail commission plans. This page is about the beauty-specific questions.
What the percentage applies to
Start with the base. Commission on gross sales pays for a sale that comes back three days later as a refund. Commission on net sales pays only on what the store keeps. Net is the safer choice, and staff come to accept it once they see how returns are handled.
Next, decide whether every product earns the same. Many stores pay one rate on everything, which is simple. Others pay a higher rate on high-margin skincare and a lower rate on discounted or brand-funded items. Whatever you choose, test it against your margins. A 6% commission on an item that earns you 30% gross margin leaves 24 points. The same 6% on a promotional item that earns 12% leaves a thin 6.
Think about what you want people to spend their time on. If the point is repeat customers, a small bonus for requests by name can sit beside the percentage. If the point is more items per basket, a goal for average ticket helps. Pick one or two goals, not six, because staff cannot chase more than that in the middle of a busy Saturday.
Gift cards are a special case. Selling a $50 gift card is not revenue that your store has earned yet, so most stores do not pay commission on it. State that in the plan so no one is surprised. See retail commission for how the term is used.
Shared sales and team selling
Pick one rule for a shared sale before the first argument. The simplest is a fixed split: a sale is split by percent between the two people who helped, such as 60/40 when one person did the consultation and another did the add-on. See commission split. Say who decides the percentage (the person who rings it up, or the manager) and write it down.
Avoid a culture where every sale needs a debate. A rule of thumb that works: the person who spent the most time with the customer is the primary, and a second person only appears if they added a specific item or did a service such as a color match. If a customer comes back and asks for someone by name, that person gets the sale.
For brand specialists employed by a vendor, the vendor usually pays them directly. In that case your own plan applies only to your staff, and you should state how a sale to that specialist's customer is credited, so there is no gap between the two systems.
Example: goal tiers and a whole-day rate
This is an example. A store pays advisers on net sales with three levels per day: 4% up to $800, 5% from $800 to $1,500, and 6% above $1,500. The rule is that the reached rate applies to the whole day, not only to the part above the line.
On Saturday, Dani sells $1,620 net. She reached the 6% level, so her commission is 6% of $1,620, which is $97.20. Under an incremental plan, she would have earned 4% on the first $800 ($32.00), 5% on the next $700 ($35.00) and 6% on the last $120 ($7.20), a total of $74.20. The whole-day rule pays her $23 more for the same sales, and that makes the last push before closing worth chasing.
On Sunday, Dani sells $700 net and earns 4%, which is $28.00. On Sunday afternoon a $120 customer returns a serum from Saturday. Her Saturday net drops to $1,500, which lands in the 5% level, so her pay for that day is recalculated at 5% of $1,500, or $75.00. The store has not overpaid, and the rule is the same for every adviser.
Two advisers share a $300 sale at 60/40. At 5% that is $15, paid as $9.00 and $6.00.
Mistakes beauty stores make with commission
- Paying on the first ring and never adjusting for returns, so staff earn on sales that reverse.
- Letting each manager invent their own rule for shared sales.
- Paying the same rate on a $9 add-on and on a $120 serum without checking the margin.
- Including gift cards in commissionable sales.
- Ignoring overtime law. Commission is part of pay for overtime purposes in many cases, and rules vary, so check with the Department of Labor or your state before designing a plan.
Setting up a plan, step by step
- Choose the base: net sales after returns is the safe default.
- List what is excluded, such as gift cards, tax and shipping.
- Set daily or period tiers, and decide whether the reached rate applies to the whole day.
- Write the shared-sale rule: a fixed percent split and who decides it.
- Write the return rule: what happens when a sale reverses in a later pay period.
- Choose how disputes work: hold the commission on a contested sale until it is settled.
- Pay on a regular pay period, for example the 1st to the 15th and the 16th to month end.
- Show staff their numbers every day so nothing is a surprise on payday.
See also how to pay commissions at a spa or salon for service-based plans, and returns in a beauty store for the policy that feeds this one.
How MazalPOS handles commissions for beauty and cosmetics stores
MazalPOS works out commission and payroll totals automatically from the sales rung up at the register. It supports goal-based rates where the reached rate applies to the whole day, a sale split by percent between two people, and commission holds on disputed sales, with fair carry-over of negative pay. Pay periods run 1st to 15th and 16th to month end. Payroll totals cover hours and commission, but MazalPOS does not file payroll taxes.
Common questions
There is no single right rate. Work backward from your gross margin, decide what share you can give to the person who made the sale, and test it on your lowest-margin products. Many plans use a few tiers so extra effort pays more.
Net is safer because it excludes returns. If you pay on gross, you pay on sales that come back, and you may have to claw money back from future paychecks, which staff dislike.
Agree a fixed percentage in advance, such as 60/40 or 50/50, and say who decides. Record the split on the sale so both shares are calculated automatically.
Often yes. Federal law has an exemption for some commissioned retail staff, but it has conditions, and many states have stricter rules. Check the Department of Labor guidance and your state before relying on it.
MazalPOS works out hours and commission totals from your sales and shifts. It does not file payroll taxes, so you still need a payroll provider or accountant for that.
Sources
Words on this page
Net salesCommission splitRetail commissionTiered commission
Want the full guide? Read Retail Commission Plans: Flat Rate, Tiers and Sales Goals.
Written by Mike Akop, founder of MazalPOS. We build and support the register, online store and staff app that stores from Las Vegas to Honolulu run on. Questions about this guide? Talk to a real person.
